rogueclassicism

quidquid bene dictum est ab ullo, meum est

Archive for the month “July, 2009”

Atlantis in Lake Baikal?

This is a new one to me (but no less silly), but it is somewhat amibiguously-worded … good to see the global economic situation hasn’t affected ‘research’ in this important area (dang … now I have to extract my firmly planted tongue from my cheek):

Russian submersibles involved in deep-water research in Siberia’s Lake Baikal could join an international expedition to search for the ancient mythical island of Atlantis, a local environmental official said on Friday.

The Mir-1 and Mir-2 mini-subs, which carried out 52 dives in Lake Baikal last summer, have recently resumed their research in the world’s deepest lake. Research earlier this week discovered evidence that most of Lake Baikal is much younger than the widely accepted age of 25 million years.

“We are planning to start an expedition to search for Atlantis. We will certainly use Mir submersibles during this expedition if they are not involved in other state-sponsored programs then,” Mikhail Slipenchuk said.

He added that the search for Atlantis, as well as studies of Lake Baikal, will be aimed at attracting public attention around the world to the urgent issue of oceanography.

Atlantis is a legendary island first mentioned in Plato’s dialogues Timaeus and Critias, which is believed to have sunk into the ocean around 9600 BC.

Atlantis has inspired literature, from science fiction to comic books to films, for centuries. Its name has become a byword for any advanced prehistoric lost civilizations.

Temple of Antinous?

Tantalizingly brief item from ORF relating the discovery of a temple built by Hadrian to Antinous (at Tivoli, presumably):

Auf dem ehemaligen Anwesen des römischen Kaisers Hadrian ist unerwartet ein Tempel gefunden worden, den er seinerzeit zu Ehren seines jungen Liebhabers Antonius erbauen ließ. Das Anwesen liegt etwa 30 Kilometer entfernt von Rom und diente einmal als Regierungs- und Wohnsitz Hadrians.

“Dies ist die bedeutendste archäologische Entdeckung seit Jahren in dieser Region”, sagte Anna Maria Reggiani, Chef-Archäologin der Region Lazio.

Hadrian war von 117 bis 138 Kaiser des römischen Imperiums und sorgte in dieser Zeit für wirtschaftlichen Aufschwung und Frieden. Das Interesse der Historiker erlangte er aber auch wegen seiner homosexuellen Neigung.

This Day in Ancient History: ante diem vi idus quinctilias

ante diem vi idus quinctilias

  • ludi Apollinares (day 5)
  • 70 A.D. — burning of the Second Temple in Jerusalem
  • 138 A.D. — death of the emperor Hadrian; dies imperii of Antoninus Pius
  • ca 150 A.D. — martyrdom of the Seven Holy Brothers (cf below … something’s not right)
  • ca 165 A.D. — martyrdom of Philip

Roman Remains in Denmark?

From the Copenhagen Post:

What was supposed to be a simple three week long research exercise for archaeology students at the University of Aarhus developed into a unique excavation project.

Remains of more than 200 bodies have been found at the dig site near Skanderborg in Jutland dating from around 2,000 years ago.

The Illerup River Valley was a deep lake measuring about 10 hectares during the Iron Age and archaeology digs have established that it was used as a major sacrificial site during that period.

The area, which is a popular location for archaeologists, is now a mixture of bog and meadow, much of which is subject to conservation laws.

The student dig began on 20 June and almost immediately began turning up human remains.

‘This was a defeated army that was sacrificed to the lake at the time. The majority of remains are large arm and leg bones, skulls, shoulder blades and pelvises,’ said Ejvind Hertz, curator from Skanderborg Museum and excavation leader.

According to Hertz, the 200 victims found so far are just a small fragment of what lies in the area, which has only been partially excavated, and estimates suggest that the figure could run to well over one thousand.

The valley was first drained in 1950 and subsequently studied intensely by archaeology teams between 1975 and 1985, when around 15,000 weapons and military objects were discovered.

Hertz said the latest find is unique as it is unusual to find the bones of sacrificial victims without their weapons.

‘It is very unusual as there has been no other find of this size before in Western Europe,’ Hertz told The Copenhagen Post.

Hertz believes the new discovery points to the river valley being used as a major sacrificial site.

‘You could consider the Illerup river valley as a central holy place. There was one god that victims were sacrificed to and another god further along the valley that received sacrificed weapons.’

The excavation was extended to four weeks and archaeologists are in the process of removing the bodies. Hertz said they hope the dig will act as a preliminary survey for a much larger, extensive excavation in the future.

So what does this have to do with the Romans? Possibly nothing … but Roman items have been found in the Illerup River Valley before. An interesting article on past finds there includes these tantalizing paragraphs:

Prior to the offering, items were deliberately spoilt. Swords were broken across and shields smashed. The round items are shield bosses, torn out of the wooden shields and then deformed by cuts and blows.

Part of the ceremony involved destroying the weapons and equipment. Next, the remnants were gathered into bundles, which were wrapped in various forms of cloth – military cloaks, for example. The bundles were then carried out onto the lake in boats and thrown overboard. These bundles have been found all over the bed of the lake, which was 250 meters wide and 400 meters long.

During the course of 18 years (spread over two periods), these ancient bundles and their contents of swords, spears, lances, shields, knives, combs, Roman silver coins, bridles, tools and much more were recovered one by one after having spent as much 1,800 years in the sediment of the lake. The finds were brought to the Moesgård Museum, preserved, described, sorted, and then compared with similar material from as far afield as the Black Sea, Scotland, Africa and the Arctic.

The Illerup finds are exceptional, because of both their sheer quantity and their condition. The alkaline nature of the soil has preserved iron so well that two hundred Roman swords, for example, could be used today had they not been ceremoniously broken and bent prior to being cast into the lake.

Two hundred Roman swords! That’s pretty strong evidence of some major arms dealing in antiquity … let’s hope they do some DNA tests on the bones to try and get a handle on national origins …

Roman Tunnel in Plovdiv

Another brief item from SNA:

Municipal employees discovered a well-preserved ancient Roman tunnel in the southern Bulgarian city of Plovdiv.

The workers were clearing up the Nebet Tepe (“Guards’ Hill”) fortress in order to turn into a tourist attraction when they came across the tunnel near the Maritsa River.

The tunnel has a fully preserved staircase and leads to the northern side of the fortress. Plovdiv’s Deputy Mayor Shopov, who is a historian himself, told the BGNES news agency that no one had any idea about the existence of the tunnel.

The clearing up of the fortress began after a month ago the Plovdiv Municipality got a permission from the Bulgarian state to be in charge of the ancient site, and to turn it into a clean and well-lit tourist attraction ready to welcome tourists.

The Guards’ Hill is one of the many historic sites in Plovdiv; it features remains of a prehistoric settlement, and in 12th century BC was the site of the Ancient Thracian city Evmolpia.

Plovdiv was one of those cities called Philippopolis in Greek times, then Trimontium when the Romans had control of the area.

When Classics Go Bad

… or something like that. TMZ alerts us to someone claiming to be the reincarnated goddess Venus de Milo who has brought a lawsuit against Hugh Hefner for something. As you can tell, this one’s really bizarre (and if someone had emailed it to me, I’d be checking Snopes and other sources; it might eventually be debunked for all I know) … here’s the ClassCon from her affidavit (which I’m actually typing because it’s so bizarre … the spelling errors are not mine):

He’s always mayed my life my adopted families lives a mess you relize he’s suppose to be the centaur of the Greek gods. And since I’m really a reincarnation, I’m really Venus Demilo the goddess. Along with roger dawson he’s odyeseuos and everyone I know knows this.

It goes on (and is potentially offensive) and there’s more ClassCon scattered throughout. Simply bizarre.

Another Comic: Athena

Dynamite Entertainment has a new mini-series based on the goddess of Wisdom:

The incipit of a review at Comic Book Resources:

Though they originated thousands of years ago, the myths and legends of ancient Greece still serve as the gateway drug for fledgling fans of all kinds of adventure fiction in the modern day. In today’s pop culture, updated versions of the gods and goddesses make their presence known in all kinds of stories set across all kinds of genres. Along those lines, Dynamite Entertainment’s four-part “Athena” series finds the goddess of wisdom and war plucked out of ancient Greece and into the wiles of modern Manhattan. With a twist, of course.

“Athena wakes up at the base of the Parthenon in modern times,” writer Doug Murray told CBR. “Remember that the Parthenon was built in honor of Athena and originally featured a heroic-sized statue of her. She has no memory of being a Goddess or participating in the events of the ancient myths so, when she recovers, she is a sort of tabula rosa—and has to find a place in the modern world. There was some talk of making her a counseler, but I felt that making her an investigator for the D.A. of New York gave more story opportunities, and that’s the way we eventually went.”

… another one to keep my eye open for …

Also Seen: Classics in Vanderbilt Magazine

Lengthy and interesting article by Taylor Holliday on Classics — past and present:

(reprinted at Clarksville Online as well)

rogueclassicism Review: Mythsongs CD

As most readers of rogueclassicism are aware, all those wonderful stories which are embraced under the category of ‘myth’ were often told in poem — or more accurately — song form. With Myth Songs, the multi-talented Nick Humez has put together a CD version of songs  he originally wrote to be sung to his myth class at Montclair State University. While the vast majority of the seventeen tracks relate to Greek Myth, there are nods to others such as Norse (Sleipnir), Egyptian (Akhnaten’s Gavotte), Sumerian (Fraglied, Inanna’s Waltz), Canaanite (Ba’al and Mot), ‘Proto-IndoEuropean’ (The Triple Goddess), and Irish (Hibernica). In this review, we’ll be focusing on the Greek ones, of course.

The opening track — Perseus — is a lengthy and witty retelling of the tale which is performed in the Irish/Scottish folk song manner which is reflected in most of the songs. It’s very complicated from a metrical point of view — again, as are many of the songs — but is not inaccessible. The theme (and style) is revisited in Three Monster-Slayers in Search of a Single Malt. One could imagine one or both of these being used to introduce students to the Perseus story or even Clash of the Titans (original or remake). By contrast, the Wilusiad and The House of Atreus both feature dulcimers, which give the songs themselves a Renaissance-like sound (for want of a better term) and establish a suitably tragic mood for the subject matter. The Oracles (which includes a bit of Roman content, inter alia, with the story of Tarquinius) is mostly a piano piece which has reminiscences of Tom Lehrer.

There is much to delight in this CD, especially if one is following along with the lyrics provided in the liner notes. A taste of the wit which characterizes many of the tracks can be seen in this excerpt from The Olympian Dozen (All 14 of ‘em):

Now Rhea was dim, and did not prevent him
From ingesting her children, one, two, three, four, five;
But the sixth she concealed, and in place of a meal
Of a boy, gave a boulder, preserving alive
Little Zeus, who (much quicker), when Cronus with liquor
Was drunk, an emetic did slip him, and there
Made his dad for to chunder (the first Jovian thunder)
And up came five siblings, no worse for the wear.

All in all, it’s a thoroughly enjoyable CD and one which would fit into any university-level myth or Classical Civilization course in some manner. It could also be used profitably, I think, at the High School/Middle School with motivated students (as long as they had access to the lyrics). Some of the songs would readily lend themselves to school projects involving a video/animation creation (with appropriate permissions, of course) and if you’re going to be hosting a Roman-style banquet, many of the songs would fit in well as an alternative or supplement to ‘traditional’ lyric poetry/epic performances.

More information (including a full list of tracks) on Mythsongs can be gleaned from official website (although the email address there may be out of date).

Pompeiiana Newsletter

Not sure if folks have noticed in the Classical Blogosphere sidebar that Andrew Reinhard has been posting back issues of the pioneering Pompeiiana newsletter … if not (or if so), folks will be interested in this missive AR sent out yesterday:

This is a quick note to say that 100 issues of Pompeiiana Newsletter are available online at: http://pompeiiana.blogspot.com

I put #100 up today, so I am about halfway into posting every issue. As always, Pompeiiana is free — click on the title of each post to open the PDF file which you can then either save to your computer or print. Today’s issue closes out 1988, the year that Pompeiiana went from a four-page tabloid to eight pages (including one full page of Latin/Classics comics, many of which were student-created).

A very useful resource if you’re a Latin teacher, and fun reading if you’re not!

Lyceum Opening Next Month

Brief item from ANA:

The archaeological site of the 4th century BC Lyceum of Aristotle, in downtown Athens, will open to the public in late July.

The Lyceum, named after its 6th century BC sanctuary to Apollo Lyceus (the “wolf-god”, from the word “lykos”, or wolf), had long been a place of philosophical discussion and debate, and had had been the meeting place of the Athenian assembly before the stablishment of a permanent meeting area on Pnyx hill in the 5th century BC.

But the Lyceum is mostly renowned for the philosophical school founded there by Aristotle upon his return to Athens in 335 BC after being the private tutror of the then young prince Alexander of Macedon, the future Alexander the Great, since 343 BC.

After his return to Athens in 335 BC and up to his death in 322 BC, Aristotle rented some buildings in the Lyceum and established a school there where he lectured, wrote most of his philosophical treatises and dialogues, and systematically collected books that comprised the first library in European history. Since Aristotle liked to walk around the grounds as he lectured, surrounded by his students, the philosophical school he founded was called Peripatetic (from ‘peripatos’, which means stroll or walkabout in Greek).

Situated just outside the walls of ancient Athens, the Lyceum was brutally sacked and razed to the ground by the Roman general Lucius Cornelius Sulla in 86 BC, but was later rebuilt.

The site’s location remained unknown for centuries until it was rediscovered in 1996 during excavations for Athens’ new Museum of Modern Art.

… hmmm … I wonder if the previously-announced plans to cover it are still a go …

This Day in Ancient History

ante diem vii idus quinctilias

ludi Apollinares (day 4)

597 B.C. — date for Thales’ eclipse (or so it was thought in several 19th century (and earlier) sources

118 A.D. — Hadrian finally arrives in Rome as emperor

Apoxyomenos Appropriations

This one’s just starting to hit the papers; apparently other fields learned from an Apoxyomenos discovery back in 1998 as well  … here’s Eurekalert’s take:

The restoration of a 2,000-year-old bronze sculpture of the famed ancient Greek athlete Apoxyomenos may help modern scientists understand how to prevent metal corrosion, discover the safest ways to permanently store nuclear waste, and understand other perplexing problems. That’s the conclusion of a new study on the so-called “biomineralization” of Apoxyomenos appearing in the current issue of ACS’ Crystal Growth & Design, a bi-monthly journal. Best known as “The Scraper,” the statue depicts an athlete scraping sweat and dust from his body with a small curved instrument.

In the report, Davorin Medakovic and colleagues point out that Apoxyomenos was discovered in 1998 on floor of the Adriatic Sea. While the discovery was a bonanza for archaeologists and art historians, it also proved to be an unexpected boon to scientists trying to understand biomineralization. That’s the process in which animals and plants use minerals from their surroundings and form shells and bone. Apoxyomenos was encrusted with such deposits.

“As studies of long-term biofouled manmade structures are limited, the finding of an ancient sculpture immersed for two millennia in the sea provided a unique opportunity to probe the long-term impact of a specific artificial substrate on biomineralizng organisms and the effects of biocorrosion,” the report said. By evaluating the mineral layers and fossilized organisms on the statue, the researchers were able to evaluate how underwater fouling organisms and communities interacted with the statue as well as how certain mineral deposits on the bronze sculpture slowed its deterioration.

From the Italian Press

… the last bit of the backlog! woohoo!

A piece of a Roman column was found in a drain during sewer work in Naples (I think):

Excavations in the Palazzo Vecchio in Florence have revealed remains of a first century theatre:

… and bits from a Temple of Isis and a pile of other remains too:

Some funerary statuary from a first century necropolis near Naples:

Remains of a Roman villa from Albettone:

A section of Etruscan/Roman road from Perugia:

Evidence from a necropolis in Ischitella suggests (maybe) an Etruscan presence there:

Organic finds from Pompeii are going to be kept in a special climate-controlled space:

They’re talking (again) of an underpass between the Temple sites at Agrigento:

… and of an archaeological park for Selinunte:

Big hopes for a dig at the Vicus Martis Tudertium:

A statue of Minerva Tritonia has been restored and is on display:

The Domus Aurea will reopen within a couple of years:

Breviaria Miscellaneaque

I’m hoping to get the last of the backlog out of my system over the course of the day …  here’s a pile of items which, for various reasons, I didn’t really get a chance to get to (again, some might be a bit old):

How’s your Classical education?:

If you didn’t do well:

I can’t remember if I mentioned this report about Rome opening up assorted underground sites like the Ludus Magnus to the public, so just in case:

Similarly, I’m not sure whether I mentioned the vandalism attack on the Ara Pacis museum a while ago:

An update of sorts on the Oded Golan trial:

On the Roman contribution to comedy:

In case you missed the Astronomy Picture of the Day of the sun rising over the Parthenon … Robert Barron has a nice list of Classically-themed APODs at his blog …

Mary Beard stepped outside her blog to compare Silvio Berlusconi to a well-known emperor:

Tom Holland had an interesting review of the influence of Arthur Evans’ excavations on other branches of the humanities:

Plenty of Romans in a top ten list of extravagant emperors:

Rather less Classcon in a top ten list of literary shipwrecks:

… and since we’re doing Top Tens, we should alert folks to Mary Beard’s recent:

I’m still trying to figure out what, exactly, Examiner.com is (an open group blog masquerading as a newspaper?) but it turns up almost daily in my scans with articles of various interest … here’s a handful of recent ones:

Hercules’ thirteenth labour:

In case you’ve never heard/read Prairie Home Campanion’s Six Minute Iliad:

Daily Kos had a thing about Psyche:

A NASCAR blogger was looking at the Circus Maximus:

Folks will want to check out the Latin section of the Tar Heel Reader

The University of Queensland has acquired a nice funerary stele from Palmyra:

Back in May, CNN had a nice little slideshow about Rome:

Greece has come out against Google Streetview for some reason:

… while Rome is trying to get a dot Roma domain designation

Assorted links:

… as is Electronic Antiquity 12.1 (November 2008) …

… as is American Journal of Archaeology 113.3

The CAAS has an incipient archive for its newsletters …

TOC for Arethusa 42.2 (Spring 2009) …

TOC for TAPA 139.1 (Spring 2009) …

Latest CANE newsletter (May 2009) …

Latest CAMWS newsletter (Spring/Summer 2009) …

Rosetta issue 6 (all articles online) …

Latest HCA newsletter (June 2009) …

Papers from the APA panel New Approaches to the Political & Military History of the Greek, Roman, and Late Roman Worlds

A preliminary program for the 2010 APA shindig

The TES had an Ancient Greece wordsearch

ArtNet has been serializing Thomas Hoving’s memoirs online …

Multi-Spectral Imaging

Seems we get a report like this every year around this time … the incipit of a piece from PhysOrg:

It might simply look like a smudge, but even the slightest stain on the ancient writing surface of papyrus could obscure a revelation of a past civilization. Now, with the advent of high-tech imaging, some of those secrets could reveal fascinating insights into everyday life of early Egyptian, Greek and Roman societies.

For the last four weeks, a team of national researchers and scholars examined dozens of papyri among the thousands of papyrological pieces in the University of Michigan collection. Using multi-spectral imaging, the Ancient Textual Imaging Group—led by acclaimed papyrology expert Stephen Bay of Brigham Young University—examined ancient text written on papyrus that had become illegible because they are stained, discolored and faded. Recording through a range of filters, the technology captures high-resolution color images, making clear the layers of text hidden beneath words and letters written on levels of papyrus.

The Ancient Textual Imaging Group, based at Brigham Young, is conducting a two-year venture to record illegible papyrus documents from historically significant U.S.-based collections. The project is supported by a grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities.

Throughout July, scholars and students at the Papyrological Institute, hosted by U-M, will examine the newly recorded images, aiming to piece together a picture of a world that until now has been hidden. Findings from the newly enhanced images of the papyri will be released as early as August.

“These new images give us insight into the writing and life of generations existing two, maybe three generations before the readable text was written,” said Arthur Verhoogt, U-M associate professor of papyrology and Greek studies.

CONF: Scientists and Professionals

… seen on the Classicists list:

SCIENTISTS AND PROFESSIONALS IN THE ANCIENT WORLD CONFERENCE
School of Classics, University of St Andrews
7-9 September 2009

Booking is now open for the ‘Scientists and Professionals in the Ancient World’
conference. Please visit the conference website:
http://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/classics/science-and-empire/scipro.shtml

A booking form (bottom of the page) may be completed on-line, or printed out and
posted (together with payment) to Mrs Margaret Goudie
(classcon AT st-andrews.ac.uk).

Booking deadline: 29 August 2009
Venue: School of Classics, Swallowgate 11, Butts Wynd, St Andrews

Conference organisers: Dr Emma Gee (ergg AT st-andrews.ac.uk), Dr Jason Koenig
(jpk3 AT st-andrews.ac.uk), Dr Katerina Oikonomopoulou (ao40 AT st-andrews.ac.uk),
Professor Greg Woolf (gdw2 AT st-andrews.ac.uk)

The conference is part of the activities of the Leverhulme project ‘Science and
Empire in the Roman World’
(http://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/classics/science-and-empire/)

The conference programme is available from the conference website:
http://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/classics/science-and-empire/scipro.shtml

This Day in Ancient History

ante diem viii idus iulias

  • ludi Apollinares (day 3) — games instituted in 212 B.C. after consulting the Sybilline books during a particularly bad stretch in the Punic Wars; four years later they became an annual festival in honour of Apollo
  • rites in honour of Vitula, possibly honouring a divinity who supposedly presided over victory celebrations … or perhaps she had something to do with heifers
  • 1851 — birth of Arthur Evans (excavator of Knossos)

CONF: Lucretius in the European Enlightenment

… seen on the Classicist list:

Lucretius in the European Enlightenment
A Conference hosted by the School of History, Classics, and Archaeology
The University of Edinburgh

3 – 4 September 2009
For more information and registration details, see
http://www.shca.ed.ac.uk/conferences/lucretius09/index.html

Programme:
David Butterfield (W.H.D. Rouse Research Fellow, Christ’s College, Cambridge):
‘Lucretius’ De rerum natura and classical scholarship in the eighteenth century’

Gianni Paganini (Professor of the History of Philosophy, Università del Piemonte Orientale, Italy):
‘Lucretius and Bayle’

Ann Thomson (Professor of British History, Université Paris 8 Vincennes-St. Denis):
‘Lucretius and la Mettrie’
Piet H. Schrijvers (Emeritus Professor of Latin, Leiden University):
‘Lucretius in the Dutch Enlightenment’
Tim Hochstrasser (Senior Lecturer in International History, London School of Economics and Political Science):
‘The role of Lucretius in Diderot’s later political thought’
Wolfgang Pross (Professor of German and Comparative Literature, University of Berne, Switzerland):
‘»Atheorum antistes et oraculum«: Enemies of Lucretius in the European Enlightenment’
James Harris (Lecturer in Philosophy, University of St. Andrews):
‘Lucretius and Hume’

Alan Charles Kors (George H. Walker Term Professor of History, University of Pennsylvania):
‘Lucretius and d’Holbach’
Avi Lifshitz (Lecturer in History, University College London):
‘Lucretius and German debates over the origins of language, c. 1750’
Mario Marino (Post-Doctoral Fellow, Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena):
‘Herder and Lucretius’

Ernst A. Schmidt (Emeritus Professor of Classics, University of Tübingen):
‘Wieland and Lucretius’
Andrew Laird (Professor of Classical Literature, University of Warwick):
‘Lucretius and Spanish Jesuit culture after the Bourbon Reforms: Diego José Abad and Rafael Landívar in Italy’

From Sword to Asp

One of the ongoing problems I have with this whole ‘tomb of Cleopatra’ thing is the assumption — it appears — that not just Cleopatra but also Antony will be found in Egyptian-style sarcophagi, all mummied up. But as with Arsinoe, I’m still not sure of what the burial practices of the Ptolemies were. Consider when the young Octavian made his journey and visited the tomb of Alexander (according to Cassius Dio 51.16, via Lacus Curtius):

After this he viewed the body of Alexander and actually touched it, whereupon, it is said, a piece of the nose was broken off. But he declined to view the remains of the Ptolemies, though the Alexandrians were extremely eager to show them, remarking, “I wished to see a king, not corpses.”

See also Suetonius, Augustus 18 … Does that suggest that the Ptolemies may have been ‘on display’ in the same manner as Alexander? I honestly don’t know. I’m also bothered by the fact that all the focus seems to have been on the manner of Cleopatra’s death and relatively little attention has been paid to what happened between that time and Antony’s death (hence the title of this post), specifically as regards the corpse of Antony. As far as I am aware, the main source for such things is Plutarch’s Life of Antony (written a century or so after the events in question, of course). In chapter 82 (via Lacus Curtius) we are told:

As for Caesarion, then, he was afterwards put to death by Caesar,— after the death of Cleopatra; but as for Antony, though many generals and kings asked for his body that they might give it burial, Caesar would not take it away from Cleopatra, and it was buried by her hands in sumptuous and royal fashion, such things being granted her for the purpose as she desired.

Keeping in mind that we’re dealing with events happening in the first couple of weeks (give or take a few days) of August, 30 B.C., we clearly aren’t dealing with a mummification opportunity, even if it is done with Cleopatra’s own hands. And from the next mention of Antony a few chapters later (84), it is clear that the obsequies are pretty much complete; just prior to Octavian’s departure for Syria:

After Cleopatra had heard this, in the first place, she begged Caesar that she might be permitted to pour libations for Antony; and when the request was granted, she had herself carried to the tomb, and embracing the urn which held his ashes, in company with the women usually about her, she said: “Dear Antony, I buried thee but lately with hands still free; now, however, I pour libations for thee as a captive, and so carefully guarded that I cannot either with blows or tears disfigure this body of mine, which is a slave’s body, and closely watched that it may grace the triumph over thee. Do not expect other honours or libations; these are the last from Cleopatra the captive. For though in life nothing could part us from each other, in death we are likely to change places; thou, the Roman, lying buried here, while I, the hapless woman, lie in Italy, and get only so much of thy country as my portion. But if indeed there is any might or power in the gods of that country (for the gods of this country have betrayed us), do not abandon thine own wife while she lives, nor permit a triumph to be celebrated over myself in my person, but hide and bury me here with thyself, since out of all my innumerable ills not one is so great and dreadful as this short time that I have lived apart from thee.”

The next chapter opens:

After such lamentations, she wreathed and kissed the urn, and then ordered a bath to be prepared for herself.

A pretty elaborate account, to be sure, and one where the translator’s decision might make a difference in regards to how the passage is interpreted. In this case, the translator (Bernadotte Perrin) tells us that Antony’s remains are in an urn. John Dryden’s translation tells us that they’re in a tomb (as do most of the other public domain translations). If we take Perrin’s translation, we might suspect that Antony was cremated in the time-honoured Roman fashion. If we take the ‘tomb’ translation, we might not be so dogmatic. Here are the relevant Greek passages from Plutarch (hat tip to DM and DP for tracking these down for me; I’m cutting and pasting from this) … I’ve highlighted the word in question:

84.3 ἡ δ’ ἀκούσασα ταῦτα πρῶτον μὲν ἐδεήθη Καίσαρος, ὅπως αὐτὴν ἐάσῃ χοὰς ἐπενεγκεῖν Ἀντωνίῳ· καὶ συγχωρήσαντος, ἐπὶ τὸν τάφον κομισθεῖσα καὶ περιπεσοῦσα τῇ [4] σορῷ μετὰ τῶν συνήθων γυναικῶν “ὦ φίλ’ Ἀντώνιε” εἶπεν [...]

85. Τοιαῦτ’ ὀλοφυραμένη καὶ στέψασα καὶ κατασπασαμένη τὴν σορόν, ἐκέλευσεν αὑτῇ λουτρὸν γενέσθαι. λουσαμένη δὲ καὶ κατακλιθεῖσα, λαμπρὸν ἄριστον ἠρίστα.

… where we clearly see the word used is “soros”, a wonderfully ambiguous word which usually does refer to an urn for cinerary ashes (according to L&S), but there are some usages which refer generally to a tomb.

If we look to Cassius Dio’s account (51.11), the obsequies for Antony are mentioned in passing:

Following out this plan, they obtained an audience with Cleopatra, and after discussing with her some moderate proposals they suddenly seized her before any agreement was reached. 5 After this they put out of her way everything by means of which she could cause her own death and allowed her to spend some days where she was, occupied in embalming Antony’s body; then they took her to the palace, but did not remove any of her accustomed retinue or attendants, in order that she should entertain more hope than ever of accomplishing all she desired, and so should do no harm to herself. At any rate, when she expressed a desire to appear before Caesar and to have an interview with him, she gained her request; and to deceive her still more, he promised that he would come to her himself.

… and the word Dio uses for ‘embalming’ is ‘taricheuo’, which is indeed the word one uses for embalming in the Egyptian sense.

Turning to Latin sources, Suetonius merely mentions in passing that he allowed them to be buried together and for the tomb they had begun to be completed (Aug. 17 via the Latin Library).

Ambobus communem sepulturae honorem tribuit ac tumulum ab ipsis incohatum perfici iussit.

The gist of all this seems to me to suggest that, by the time Plutarch et al were recounting this, the story of Cleo’s death had become elaborated on in so many ways that no one really had any idea what the details were. The ancient sources were fascinated by that whole asp thing and seem to be making their own assumptions when it comes to the burial of both Antony and Cleopatra. What is interesting, though, is that the only suggestion that mummification might be involved comes from a passing word from the epitome of Cassius Dio …

Post Navigation