Pre-Roman Silchester Town Planning? NOT NEWS!

The BBC is really starting to bug me as regards coverage of archaeology. Of late, it appears the only things it feels worth covering are those which ‘happen’ to be associated with its Digging for Britain series. The problem is, of course, that there generally isn’t anything ‘new’ about it, but my email and social network feeds are all abuzz with the exciting ‘news’. A case in point is the latest thing clogging up the airwaves:

Archaeologists believe they have found the first pre-Roman planned town discovered in Britain.

It has been unearthed beneath the Roman town of Silchester or Calleva Atrebatum near modern Reading.

The Romans are often credited with bringing civilisation to Britain – including town planning.

But excavations have shown evidence of an Iron Age town built on a grid and signs inhabitants had access to imported wine and olive oil.

Prof Mike Fulford, an archaeologist at the University of Reading, said the people of Iron Age Silchester appear to have adopted an urbanised ‘Roman’ way of living, long before the Romans arrived.

“It is very remarkable to find this evidence of a planned Iron Age layout before the arrival of the Romans and the development of a planned, Roman town,” he said.

“Indeed, it would be hard to see a significant difference between the lifestyles of the inhabitants of the Iron Age town and of its Roman successor in the 1st Century AD.”

He said they seem to have been drinking wine and using olive oil and a fermented fish sauce called garum in their cooking, all imported from abroad.

Silchester is famous for the most complete Roman town walls in Britain.

After the Roman invasion, the town was used by its military, and there is evidence that Roman buildings were very swiftly built on top of Iron Age structures.

Prof Fulford believes that shortly before this, the town may have been taken over by the British Iron Age chieftain Caratacus – a leader of the Catuvellauni tribe – as his stronghold.

The evidence comes from coins minted by Caratacus in the area.

“Both their tight distribution in central southern England and their style point to Calleva as being the source of Caratacus’ coins,” he said.

Caratacus was a hero of the British resistance to Roman rule. He famously took on the invading Roman army at the Battle of Medway and after his capture was taken to Rome where he appeared so fearless that the Emperor Claudius was moved to spare his life.

As for the fate of the Roman town, a scorched layer within the archaeology suggests that it was actually burnt to the ground, and seems to have been abandoned for about 20 years.

It is possible that this destruction was carried out by the Queen of the Iceni tribe, Boudicca, or at least at the time of her anti-Roman rebellion in 60 – 61 AD.

It is known from the Annals of Tacitus that Boudicca and her army laid waste to the Roman towns of Colchester (Camulodunum), London (Londinium) and St Albans (Verulamium), but could Silchester have been a fourth, previously unknown Roman settlement to fall victim to Boudicca’s rebellion?

If these theories are correct, then within a single generation Silchester went through a period of turbulent evolution from a prosperous and sophisticated Iron Age town, to being under direct Roman army control to being burned to the ground and deserted.

 

via: ‘Britain’s first pre-Roman planned town’ found near Reading | BBC

Okay … I’m first to admit this is a very interesting story and in the past I’ve mentioned that Silchester must be an incredibly interesting dig. But let’s have a bit of a flashback:

  • Pre Roman Silchester … which first mentions the pre-Roman town planning (and some puppy skinning too … remember that? (July 2009))

… I’m all for hyping Silchester and all the wonderful work Dr Fulford has been doing there for 13 or 14 years now (maybe more), but please do not present it as news!!!! At a bare minimum, in the ‘related stories’ box, link to your previous coverage BBC! It strikes me as intellectually dishonest not to …

About these ads

2 thoughts on “Pre-Roman Silchester Town Planning? NOT NEWS!

  1. It’s quite funny really – of course this isn’t ‘news’ in the sense that it is fresh information, it’s written by the assistant producer of the series specifically to trail the broadcast, which is new.

    Their job is to spread information to the populous and they should be praised for the job they do at this. To the expert I don’t recommend criticising a mass media outlet for their definition of ‘new’, as their target audience is necessarily broad and therefore amateur. If you really want to criticise definitions of ‘new’ then have a look through any number of academic jounals to find rehashed, reheated and reinterpreted research.

    • Hardly an analogous situation … tv hype masquerading as news essentially turns the BBC into “Entertainment Tonight” …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s