rogueclassicism

quidquid bene dictum est ab ullo, meum est

Archive for the month “August, 2011”

Eridanos, Ilissos, and Kifissos

Very interesting feature from Kathimerini:

Archaeologists have many tools at their disposal these days, from handpicks and sharp triangular trowels for excavation to sophisticated computer-graphic software and high-tech laboratory processes for virtual reconstruction and date determination. But the most basic, powerful equipment in the diverse archaeological toolkit remains the imagination. With the ancient landscape in Athens now buried beneath asphalt streets and massive modern buildings, the imagination is more important than ever for both archaeologists and laymen alike when considering the physical setting in which past Athenians once pursued their daily lives. The huge disparity between the former, comparatively natural landscape that lay around the Athenian Acropolis – once the center of the ancient city – and today’s starkly unnatural, paved-over urban environment makes it difficult to comprehend just how different Athens once was but small topographical clues survive on and under the ground, in the Acropolis Museum and among the words of ancient authors.

Open, free-flowing watercourses and freshwater springs are one of the most conspicuous natural features of the ancient landscape missing in today’s central Athenian environment. Two perennial rivers flowed through ancient Athens – the Eridanos and the Ilissos. The Eridanos, rising from beneath Mount Lycabettus, followed a course north of the Acropolis, past the Athenian Agora and the gates and cemetery of the Kerameikos. The Ilissos, streaming down from Mt Hymettus, where its headwaters included a spring still to be seen at Kaisariani Monastery, ran south of the Acropolis along a route today delineated in part by sections of Vassileos Constantinou, Ardittou and Kallirrois streets. These two rivers (actually streams) came together west of the Acropolis, flowed into the larger Kifissos, and eventually emptied into the sea at Faliro Bay.
The Eridanos and Ilissos rivers were vital sources of fresh water in antiquity for drinking, washing, cooking, religious purification, industry and waste removal. Portions of the Eridanos, running through the heart of the ancient city, were already lined with built walls by 478 BC and its waters appear from historical accounts to have been occasionally less pure than those of the further outlying Ilissos. The geographer Strabo (9.1.19) reports in the early 1st century AD that although the Eridanos had previously been reputed to be unfit even for animal consumption, it was now “pure and potable water… outside the Gates of Diochares… near the Lyceum.” Pollution in antiquity, like today, was a problem that required monitoring and occasional regulation. An inscribed 420 BC decree discovered near the Lysicrates Monument forbids the softening of animal hides in the Ilissos River upstream of the Sanctuary of Hercules (a spot south of the Olympieion, where today Vouliagmenis Avenue intersects Ardittou and Kallirrois streets).

The riverbanks of ancient Athens were areas where city dwellers could find not only water but also cool, shady retreats in which to socialize, worship, practice military and athletic skills or pursue their studies. To imagine the relative lushness that once characterized these areas, one might extrapolate from the delightful microenvironment still preserved in the Kerameikos, where the Eridanos’ now-tiny channel continues to be lined with tall reeds and seasonally inhabited by croaking frogs. The Ilissos, too, until the late 19th century, was abundantly reedy, frequently flooded and known locally as a haven for frogs. Unlike today, however, trees grew sparsely in ancient Athens. The slopes and plains surrounding the Acropolis were probably quite barren of trees – just as they still appear to be in early modern paintings and archival 19th- and early 20th-century photographs. But along riverbanks, trees and bushes were a more common feature. Plato (“Phaedrus” 229) describes Socrates and Phaedrus strolling along the northern bank of the Ilissos, crossing the stream bed, then finding a large plane tree (platanos) under which to rest – probably located, according to archaeologist John Travlos, at the foot of Ardittos Hill where the Panathenaic Stadium was later built. Phaedrus remarks, “I am fortunate, it seems, in being barefoot; you are so always. It is easiest then for us to go along the brook with our feet in the water and it is not unpleasant, especially at this time of the year and the day.” Then he asks Socrates, “Do you see that very tall plane tree?… There is shade there and a moderate breeze and grass to sit on…”

Three gymnasia were erected in the 6th century BC beside Athens’ rivers: the Academy near the Kifissos, the Lyceum near the Eridanos and the Kynosarges near the Ilissos. Shrines and temples were also familiar riverside features – especially along the Ilissos. The area of the Kallirroe Spring, which once spilled into the Ilissos just south of the Olympieion, was a particular focus of worship. Participants in the Lesser Eleusinian Mysteries may have purified themselves there. Nearby, altars, shrines and temples were dedicated to various divinities including Boreas, the Ilissian Muses, Cronus and Rhea, Zeus and Hera, Apollo Delphinios, Artemis Agrotera, Pan, Acheloos and the Nymphs. Athenian brides on their wedding day bathed in sacred water drawn from the Kallirroe Spring in special vessels (loutrophoroi), then made offerings of these vessels at the shrine of the Nymphe on the south slope of the Acropolis. Painted loutrophoroi recovered from the shrine, depicting these premarital purification rites, are displayed in the Acropolis Museum. Natural springs and fountain houses also existed around the Acropolis itself, including one within a cave at the back of the Asclepius sanctuary on the south slope and another hidden within a deep fissure (the Klepsydra) on the northwest slope.

The importance of local water resources, especially rivers, to the ancient Athenians was visually demonstrated by two sculpted figures of river gods accompanied by two water nymphs at each end of the Parthenon’s Western Pediment (as reconstructed by specialist Olga Palagia), which represented the Eridanos and Ilissos rivers and provided a geographical framework for the pediment’s main scene – just as the real rivers similarly framed the city of Athens. The Ilissos finally disappeared during street development in the 1950s but the Eridanos can still be seen, and heard, in the Kerameikos and beneath Monastiraki Square (see below).

Flowing freely
Three members of the former architectural team responsible for the now-completed renovation of Monastiraki Square, Nikos Kazeros, Christina Parakente and Eleni Tzirtzilaki, once eloquently protested a plan to fully encapsulate the Eridanos River within a glass cover inside the Monastiraki metro station – where its ancient, stone-built channel has been incorporated as an open-air archaeological exhibit.
In a blog dated Wednesday, August 27, 2008, they wrote: “We feel that everybody has the right to see and hear the Eridanos stream; such contact is another way of experiencing history and civilization, along with the hidden natural landscape of the city.”

New from Didaskalia 8

I’m kind of confused about how Didaskalia operates … a while back, we posted their ‘latest issue’s’ TOC, but it appears that some things have been added in the meantime … here’s one set of new items (their description):

We are pleased to present a collection of pieces (8.07–8.11), organized by former Didaskalia editor Jane Montgomery Griffiths, on the Sydney Theatre Company’s 2008 production of The Women of Troy, adapted by Tom Wright and Barrie Kosky and directed by Kosky. Elizabeth Hale, guest editor for the collection, introduces the production and the articles, which include essays from Helen Slaney, Michael Halliwell, Michael Ewans, and Marguerite Johnson.

… which I became aware of because my spiders brought back these:

Socrates opens the Edinburgh Book Festival (sort of)

From an item in the Scotsman:

WHEN westen civilisation began, it was in the Agora, or marketplace, of Athens. There, in the Golden Age of Athenian democracy, about 450 years before the birth of Christ, Socrates – the man who, remember, thought the unexamined life not worth living – would contribute his pennyworth to discussions of ethics.

We know of him, said the wonderful Bettany Hughes, on the opening day of the book festival that wisely doesn’t call itself the Agora of the North, only through the works of three people – Plato, Aristophanes and Xenephon. Socrates wrote nothing himself – or at least nothing that we know about.

So why start a book festival by mentioning him? Because of this one fact.When Socrates was born, in 469BC, the population of Athens was about 200,000. When he died, 70 years later, it was 20,000.

Now this was a man who would have bumped into Euripides, who had Plato as a student, who would have gone to the first nights of Aristophanes’s plays and heard Pericles speak. The best of us, in other words. But through war (his democracy voted for war every other year, Hughes pointed out), disease and state-sanctioned “disappearances”, look at how heavily death weighed on that city, that civilisation, that first democracy.

I’d never realised that. It’s the sort of fact you might pick up at Charlotte Square, that well-known northern marketplace of ideas, which starts to put other ideas into focus. How, for example, did Socrates believe the examined life should be lived? “He is always saying that we need to look to the good in people,” said Hughes. “The world can only be good if we are our best possible selves.”

Forget, in other words, all those images from last week’s news, of people carrying off looted plasma screen TVs back to their unexamined lives and streets such as the one Hughes herself lives on in Ealing, where neighbours were threatened by men with knives and cars were set on fire. Civilisation stands firmer than that. It stands so firm that it survives even when 90 per cent of your city’s population is wiped out.

Yet Socrates, Hughes added, would have had a lot to say on mindless materialism. He would certainly have known that new trainers, looted or not, wouldn’t have made us happy. He was suspicious of the written word “because onceit goes out into the world it can be twisted, so he wouldn’t have been surprised at looters messaging”, but he believed in human beings meeting, in discussions, in questions and answers. Socrates would have hated books, in other words, but loved book festivals.

via Book festival: Do you fear the breakdown of society? Ancient Greece has lessons for us | Scotsman.

Circumundique – August 14, 2011

Yesterday’s posts:

Classics Confidential: Aristophanes at Bayards Hill Primary School

Something a bit different from the Classics Confidential folks this time around … Lorna Robinson talks about (and shows) some of her efforts associated with the Iris Project:

This Day in Ancient History: ante diem xviii kalendas septembres

ante diem xviii kalendas septembres

  • 29 B.C. — triple triumph of Octavian (day 3)

Circumundique – August 13, 2011

What the Classical blogosphere was talking about on Saturday:

Circumundique – August 12, 2011

I’m thinking I better post these before other things cause them to scroll away:

 

Speaking of Ovid …

… and the Huffington Post … the latter has a lengthy item from Narrative Magazine focussing on Diane Middlebrook’s final years (as she was working on a biography of Ovid — she was working on it at the time of her death in 2008; not sure if it was ever published). Here’s a bit from the middle … it’s an interesting (and sad) , but melancholy read overall:

The project Diane turned to with her customary verve after “Her Husband” was a biography of the Roman poet Ovid, who rejected his family legacy of membership in the Roman senate and instead became the most famous poet of his era, author of the “Metamorphoses”—a writer intrigued by transformations and also overtly concerned with the survival of his art beyond his lifetime. In the prime of his life, at the apex of his brilliant career, Ovid did something that so offended the deified Caesar Augustus that he was exiled to the barbaric outskirts of the empire and never allowed to return to Rome.

Diane had been reading and studying Ovid since graduate school, had taught him and lectured on him numerous times over the years, and it was not on a whim that she finally dug in to write his biography. Even so, it was an ambitious project since there is virtually no biographical material on Ovid beyond the pages of his own works. Most of what is factually known about Ovid comes from his letters from exile, which were not merely private correspondences but poems intended for posterity by their author, who was certain his words would last. It was Ovid’s confidence in his survival that had always intrigued Diane, and she closed the introduction to her book with a poem Ovid wrote to his stepdaughter from the lonely shore of the Black Sea, urging her not to give up on art:

In brief, there’s nothing we own that isn’t mortal

save talent, the spark of the mind.

Look at me . . .

they’ve stripped me of all they could take,

yet my talent remains my joy, my constant companion:

over this, Caesar could have no rights. What if

some savage’s sword should cut short my existence?

When I’m gone, my fame will endure,

and while from her seven hills Mars’ Rome in triumph

still surveys a conquered world, I shall be read.

As the four years unfolded during which Diane was working on Ovid and—suddenly, unexpectedly—fighting for her life, Ovid’s words took on an urgent poignancy that none of us who loved her, still less Diane herself, had anticipated. “I am not ready to die,” she said again and again, her voice brisk and decisive, that elegant index finger held aloft, underscoring a declarative that carried with it a refusal to become anything but what through will and self-confidence and keen intelligence and pluck she had determined herself to be. She was not going to be a victim, and she was not going to give up. In the face of Diane’s strategic and uncompromising pursuit of survival—looking at this woman so rampantly alive—it was impossible, inconceivable, to think otherwise.

Cleopatra – Met Artwork of the Day

William Wetmore Story’s neoclassical (and somewhat boring) sculpture of Cleo is the Met’s artwork of the day:

Socrates as Islamic Prophet?

It’s always interesting to see how non-Western cultures deal with our subject matter. This is a book reviewish/hypish thing from the Iran Book News Agency:

Seyyed Abdolhadi Ghazayi said his book deals with the philosophy of Socrates and the backgrounds to the emergence of his philosophy.

Referring to the history of philosophy before Socrates, Ghazayi explained: “Before Socrates philosophy existed in the East and then it travelled to the west. Therefore, we can infer that Socrates is the heir of Eastern philosophies of his time. An analysis of the emergence of Socrates and his remaining works makes another chapter of this volume.”

Ghazayi added: “For this book I have used a simple writing style intentionally avoiding difficult expressions. My stress on simple writing even includes philosophical terms of Socrates.”

His interest in Socrates began with his interest in classical Greek philosophers and added: “A sage should, first of all, be a theologian and so was Socrates. I consider him a divine prophet. God has not revealed the names of all his prophets to us, and since Socrates was a theologian I have no doubt that he has been a divine messenger.”

Ghazayi continued: “Each prophet had a particular mission in his life and the significance of that mission in a historical period made him everlasting in history. Some philosophers do not even regard Socrates as a sage, whereas he was martyred in the path of philosophy and theosophy.”

He added: “Philosophy is a kind of knowledge that departs from theology. Islamic philosophers are not pure philosophers. What was translated into Arabic and given to Arabs of that time was pure philosophy, but Farabi, Ibn Roshd and Ibn Sina mingled it with Quranic sciences.”

He continued: “Ibn Sina’s The Healing is a philosophical text inspired by Islamic tradition and Quran.”

Socrates’s words could not be understood in his time and that was why he was killed by poison, explained Ghazayi. His manners and ideas were unique among his disciples. They used to drink wine whereas Socrates avoided it. In fact, he was the first person that banned drinking and this proves that he had a relative understanding of Divine law.

Ghazayi emphasized: “The surviving works of Socrates show that he stood beyond the ideas of his contemporaries and taught them what was useful for their minds and bodies. Theology had no meaning for the people of that time, but he instructed people of divine knowledge lake a wise prophet.”

“Sage Socrates” is published by Koumeh and Negaran Ghalam Publications in 1000 copies.

Five Thracian Tombs from Mogilets

Another tantalizingly brief item from Novinite:

Bulgarian archeologist announced Friday the latest precious and unique finds in the country, discovered near the village of Mogilets in the area of the town of Omurtag in northeastern Bulgaria.

100 objects have been found during the digs of 5 tombs.

The area around Mogilets is the most researched in the entire Targovishte region because it has a large number of mounds and a villa, dating from Roman times, as a geo-magnetic test had shown.

The place is also among the very few in Bulgaria that have been spared from illegal treasure hunters.

Archeologist, Stefan Ivanov, quoted by the Bulgarian new agency BGNES, says four of the tombs are in close proximity to each other. The way the burials have been done leads to the conclusion the toms date from Thracian times.

The finds need to undergo restoration before being displayed for the public.

Putin Dives Phanagoria II – As Suspected

Tip o’ the pileus to the Huffington Post who brings up Putin’s dive which we mentioned the other day and links to a video of the ‘adventurer’  on the dive … ecce:

 

As my late father would say, “Don’t eat that Elmer … that’s bullsh**” … such staged garbage … they’re in less than two metres of water …

Ovid Never Exiled?

Interesting article on the Ars Amatoria up at the International League of Antiquarian Booksellers blog (I thing it’s a blog) which mentions, inter alia:

Then there’s another theory that has bounced around scholars for the last century or so: Ovid never was exiled. The main reason for this theory is that the only record of it is Ovid’s, except for “dubious” mentions by Pliny the Elder and Statius, but no one else until the 4th century CE. He did apparently die in Tomis in 17 CE, however, and has been adopted by Romanian nationalists as “The First Romanian Poet”.

I didn’t realize that the ‘phoney exile’ claim was still kicking around — near as I can tell, it hasn’t really been around (i.e. taken seriously)  for at least twenty years or so. For a summary of the scholarship , check out the Wikipedia article’s section on ‘exile’ upon which the above appears to be based. Whatever the case, it’s one of those ‘literary oppositional arguments’ which can stand up because of the nature of our sources, but really is the Classics Department version of a conspiracy theory.

Classics Confidential: Henry Stead and Helen Slaney

Today it’s a bit different … the Classics Confidential folks are interviewing the folks responsible for staging Seneca’s Medea back in February:

There’s a somewhat disturbing trailer for the production at the Oxford Medea webpage (blog?)  as well … There are also some clips from other productions of Medea (movie treatments) … Pasolini’s has always been a fave of mine …

Some of the posts that turned up in my RSS reader yesterday:

This Day in Ancient History: pridie idus sextiles

pridie idus sextiles

  • rites in honour of Hercules Invictus in the Circus Maximus
  • rites in honour of Venus Victrix, Honos, Virtus, and Felicitas in Pompey’s theatre
  • 3 A.D. — conjunction of Jupiter and Venus (one suggestion for the ‘Star of Bethlehem’)
  • 305 A.D. — martyrdom of Anicetus and companions at Nicomedia
  • 1867 — birth of Edith Hamilton (The Greek Way)

 

rcReview: Rome – From the Origins to Italy’s Capital (Quebec City)

Well, since not a heckuva lot seems to be happening, I can do some catching up with things … one of the things we opened our summer up with was with a trip to Quebec City to drop one of our kids off at a French immersion course he was taking at Laval. While driving about, we noticed ads for something called Rome: From the Origins to Italy’s Capital at the Musée de la civilisation and it turned out it is a major exhibit of assorted items throughout Rome’s history (Roman times to the nineteenth century) .  Sadly, they didn’t let anyone take photos, but I feigned ignorance of that, so here’s a taste of some of the items … but I should note that the Capitoline she-wolf is the initial item as soon as you wade past the kiddie-campers plugging the entrance; the exhibition buys the made-in-medieval-times dating for that (we might have a post on that later; we’ve been chatting with Dorothy King on related matters). Anyhoo, here’s a couple of the items in the exhibition which I managed to record for posterity … first up, a bust of Virgil which I thought was rather too far back for proper viewing:

Bust of Virgil

Next, we have a very nice chief Vestal, which is probably familiar to many of you and a good indication of some of the quality items that make up the exhibition:

Vestal

… and the last of the photos that turned out is an incredibly nice mosaic depicting the lighthouse at Alexandria (which I have never seen before):

Lighthouse

Other items at the exhibition include a nice mosaic of an athlete, some surgical instruments and coins, a few sarcophagi (including some early Christian items) and other busts (there’s a section devoted to the Roman family), and a nice decree of Pompey from Spain. The medieval items are okay, as are the Renaissance items, but after that I sort of lost interest and kept wandering back to the ancient section. The exhibition is on until the end of January or thereabouts and is definitely worth a look if you’re in the area. In case you missed the official site link above, here it is again

Tyre’s World Heritage Status Threatened?

From the Daily Star:

In Tyre, the city’s past is very much present. A fisherman in shallow waters stands near massive stone columns that are only partially covered by the Mediterranean.

In shallower waters, a man who appears to be snorkeling startles upon approach, as it becomes clear he is actually sifting for small treasures.Above the water rises a road bordered by stone columns. There are fragments of mosaic on the road, and vegetation grows freely within Roman baths and an amphitheater. A few tourists are reading from a guidebook before entering the site.

Tyre’s heritage isn’t just known by locals, as the presence of foreign tourists suggests. It is, in fact, a UNESCO World Heritage Site. But recently, reports have emerged that the ancient sites of the city once visited by Herodotus are in danger due to, among other factors, a lack of conservation. It’s been said UNESCO is considering revoking the city’s valued status. While these accounts contain kernels of truth, they have largely ignored the fact that Tyre is in the midst of a major conservation project. As to the question of city’s UNESCO status, it seems to have largely stemmed from bureaucratic error.

Hasan Dbouk, the mayor of Tyre, is clearly proud of the city’s history. If Tyre were taken off the list of World Heritage Sites, “we of course will lose,” he says. “But our loss will be small, compared to the loss to world heritage.”

Dbouk says he heard about the potential change in status through statements made by Maha al-Khalil Chalabi, of the International Association to Save Tyre. But it all seems to have started with two recent decisions issued by the UNESCO World Heritage Committee.

In advance of a meeting this June, the committee issued a set of draft decisions. The draft about Tyre made the city’s conservation situation out to be dire. It expressed a variety of concerns, including major and often illegal urban development and insufficient maintenance of sites. These concerns were based on past reports, as the draft said Lebanon had not submitted a “state of conservation report” as is requested by all states involved in the World Heritage scheme.

The Culture Ministry controls the archaeological sites in Tyre, and according to sources there who are familiar with the situation, Lebanon did in fact submit a report on current works, but it was sent to the wrong forwarding party. Once they realized the error, the officials say they rushed a new report to UNESCO in advance of the June meeting.

This is reflected in UNESCO’s final June decision, which does not mention all of its previous concern. It does ask the country to submit an update by February 2012, “with a view to considering, in the case of confirmation of the ascertained potential danger to Outstanding Universal Value, the possible inscription of the property on the List of World Heritage in Danger.”

The sources say they are in communication with UNESCO officials, will submit the requested update, and have invited UNESCO experts to visit Tyre on Oct. 2.

All of this doesn’t mean Tyre’s heritage is not in danger. At the archaeological site in Bass, which includes numerous sarcophagi and a massive sandstone arch said to be built during the reign of Emperor Hadrian in the second century A.D., the heads of stone figures carved on some tombs have been chipped off by grave robbers. Empty bottles mix with bones inside some graves. Outdated restorations that used iron bars as reinforcements are rusty and expanding in the structures they are meant to hold up.

Illegal buildings rise out of the neighboring Bass Palestinian refugee camp because there is no space for the population to grow, Dbouk says, and trash from the new buildings is finding its way into the archaeological site.

But workers can be seen building a wall to separate the Bass site from the camp. They are part of a major conservation project that is under way in Tyre, an effort that complicates the UNESCO debate.

The scheme is called the Cultural Heritage and Urban Development Project. It is currently focusing on the city’s old port, but also deals with other sites around the city.

Funded by the French Development Agency, the Italian government, the World Bank, and the Lebanese government, CHUD projects are notable for their connection to UNESCO – they only exist in Lebanese areas marked as UNESCO World Heritage Sites.

Maha al-Khalil Chalabi, of the International Association to Save Tyre, is a critic of the CHUD scheme. In a statement, she called the port project “chaotic,” and said that a planned new building “will be built on an illegal site and conflicts with the architecture of Tyre’s maritime façade … the development threatens to put Tyre … on the list of endangered cultural heritage.

For his part, Dbouk believes talk of removing Tyre from its list of heritage, in addition to taking “millions of dollars” of funding out of the CHUD project, isn’t helping the situation of a city that needs more assistance.

“Instead of being passive, [UNESCO] can provide advice and help. It the aim is conservation, help in conservation; everyone knows that we do not have enough money for this … And if there is a lack of capacity, they can help in building capacity. They shouldn’t just deal with this [issue] by signing a paper.”

Gladiator Sting at Colosseum

From AFP (yes, it is a slow news day so far):

Italian police have arrested 20 gladiator impersonators in an undercover sting aimed at ending a violent racket operating around Rome’s most famous tourist sites, Italian press reported on Thursday.

Police disguised as gladiators, dustbin men and members of the public raided the gang made up of seven families working with five tourist agencies.

The modern gladiators are accused of attacking and intimidating competitors for a lucrative business in which gladiators collect up to 10 euros ($14) for having their picture taken alongside tourists in front of attractions.

The police officers disguised as gladiators were beaten up by the alleged criminal gladiators before other undercover officers swooped in.

“Gladiators” are a feature of the Roman landscape for tourists, with men decked out in bright red capes, helmets with plumes of red feathers and sandals while carrying swords and round shields.

They can be found outside the Colosseum, Castel Sant’Angelo, Piazza Venezia and even in front of St Peter’s Basilica in the Vatican, preying on the millions of tourists who pass through Rome every year.

Criminal gangs had divided up these tourist sights and were defending their territory with violence, the police said.

Five competitors who had been chased away alerted police to the gang’s activities, leading to the sting operation.

Post Navigation