I’ve almost got my inbox to zero and finally have a chance to give attention to some things that are a few weeks old. Back at the end of November, the BBC was hyping an exposeish show about David Elkington:
Questions have been raised over the claims of a self-styled archaeologist who is arguing that a set of supposedly ancient Christian books is genuine.
David Elkington, from Gloucestershire, has raised tens of thousands of pounds to support his work proving the authenticity of the Jordan Codices.
A BBC investigation found that academics have cast doubt on Mr Elkington’s claims the codices date back to the 1st Century AD.
Mr Elkington insists the codices are genuine and he will pay back any loans he has received.
Among his backers was Princess Elizabeth of Yugoslavia, who funded his work and trips to the Middle East.
She now believes the codices are not authentic and has asked for the return of her funding.
Mr Elkington’s companies have also received thousands of pounds from investors over the years for a film project, which he says is now on hold.
He now plans to release a book about the codices, called Divine Revelation, and to produce a film based on it. He has also tried to raise sponsorship in America.
Mr Elkington, 50, claims to have previously published a “highly-acclaimed academic thesis” and to have trained under a curator of the Petrie Museum in London.
His book was a self-published work and the woman he trained under was never the curator of the Petrie museum.
He says he has a team of international experts working on the codices but was only prepared to offer the names of two academics currently advising him. They declined to comment.
The codices were found in Jordan but are currently held in Israel.
The Israel Antiquities Authority has examined some of the codices and a spokesman said: “They were shown to experts on the period; all the experts absolutely doubted their authenticity.”
The Jordanian government has yet to make an official announcement.
However, Dr Peter Thonemann, a lecturer in ancient history at Oxford University, said: “I’m as certain as it is possible to be that this entire body of codices are modern fakes. I would stake my academic reputation on it.”
Robert Feather, an author who has also seen the collection, is also sceptical about Mr Elkington’s claims the codices are ancient Christian texts.
He said: “While David Elkington continues to push the idea that these are incredibly important early Christian documents then speculation will be rife and the story will go on and on.”
In a statement, Mr Elkington and his wife said: “We acknowledge a small personal debt owed to (Princess) Elizabeth, which has never been disputed and will be paid back in full.
“David has never claimed to have had any formal qualifications and has been largely self-taught and has worked as an independent scholar. He has always been upfront about this.”
… since that time, the segment of the program (Inside Out West) has made it to Youtube and is definitely worth watching if you’ve been following this story:
In case that gets taken down, here’s the skinny/random notes I scrawled down as I watched:
- Elkington is referred to as “Gloucester’s own Indiana Jones” … the IJ epithet increasingly seems to mark out folks making outlandish claims
- Robert Feather and Elkington have had a “falling out” over how the codices were to be “exploited”
- Feather shows a couple of the codices of the 70 or so he’s seen; he doubts the authenticity of these two in particular
- Peter Thonemann is willing to stake his reputation that all of them are fakes
- Apparently Elkington accepted that verdict, but thought that others were genuine
- Elkington is clinging to the claim that the lead is old and has a team of experts
- Philip Davis of Sheffield declined to be interviewed
- Margaret Barker would only take part if she wasn’t edited in any way; the BBC declined
- then we get all the ‘death threats’ etc., that was part of the story ages ago
- Elkington was trying to raise money to get things moving
- Nice segment questioning Elkington’s self-claimed credentials
- Elkington’s “estranged son from a former marriage” comments on his father’s predeliction for story-telling and the sensationalization of the whole story
- Princess Elizabeth of Yugoslavia apparently has lent Elkington “tens of thousands of pounds”, but now has had a falling out as well
- Elkington declined to appear on camera but issued a statement which attempts to explain some of the discrepancies (not very well)
In other words, Elkington’s credibility seems to be completely and totally shot at this point. We should also point out that just prior to the airing of this program, a pile of photos and posts were taken down from the Jordan Codices facebook page (which undoubtedly was/is an Elkington production).
… and just to ‘catch up’ a bit more, here’s some bloggery worth reading:
- Philip Davies again on the Jordan Codices (Paleojudaica … November 4, 2012)
- More Lead Codices, More Stamps… (The Aramaic Blog … June 27, 2012)
- Jordan Codices: More About the Altered Metallurgical Report (ibid … September 14, 2011)
- Jordan Lead Codices: Another Stamp Found (The Musings of Tom Verenna … September 14, 2012)
- Remember Those Lead Codices? (September 3, 2011 … us; that should be enough)