Barry Baldwin ~ Don’t Let the Sun Catch You Lying

Reprinted with kind permission of the author himself, who years ago had to endure yours truly as a student. Errors in transcription accrue to the latter.

(Apologies to Gerry & The Pacemakers) Some amiable marginalia to Patrick Mahoney’s excellent piece [FT275.49] on Constantine’s vision

Lactantius’s (c250 – c. 325) Latin account precedes the Greek one of Eusebius. He doesn’t claim Constantine himself as the source,  but must have been close to the Emperor, the latter having appointed him tutor to royal son Crispus c. 317.

Depending which text you read — there has been much editorial emendation (for details. TD Barnes, Constantine and Eusebius. Cambridge, Mass. 1981, p309 n146), one (J. Rougé) deleted the entire sign description – the emblem was either the Chi-Rho  Christogram or the Staurogram, already established the third century symbol of the Cross (JL Creed, Lactantius: De Mortibus Persecutorum , Oxford, 1984.119 n9).

Lactantius later (DMP, cb46) claims another miraculous dream, an angel appearing in Constantine’s then colleague and fellow-Christian Licinius prior to another civil war battle. As Mahoney says, these ages abounded in miraculous visions. For easy example, the barbarian general Gainas had an angelic warning during civil strife c. 400; the Virgin Mary made several guest appearances over Constantinople (Virgin on the ridiculous?), and so on.

Barnes (806 1147) suggests the story may also have been inspired by Judas’s dream in 2 Maccabees 15. Other possible parallels could include the Rain Miracle wrought by the prayers of Christian soldiers in Marcus Aurelius’s army (see, ag. Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, bks ch5), plus the simple fact that Roman rulers from Romulus on had dreams and visions good and bad at critical moments ( Liry, Roman History, bk1 ch7 para1: Suetonius, Life of Augustus, ca 95 — same vulturine phenomenon.

Incidentally, there was a more fortean moment on the other side at this critical battle. The pagan Greek chronicler Zosimus (New History, bk2 ch16) reports, “When Maxentius had led his forces out of Rome and crossed the bridge, owls in endless number flew down and covered the wall,” a sight that encouraged Constantine to join battle.

Eusebius’s Life of Constantine abounds in dubious details of TG Elliott, “Eusebian Frauds in the Vita Constantini,” Phoenix 45, 1991, 162-71. Discrepancies between this and his Ecclesiastical History have induced some scholars to doubt his authorship of the biography.

Mahoney’s solar-ice particles explanation was anticipated by e.g., AHM Jones, Constantine and the Conversion of Europe (1949). p96; Barnes, p306 n147; P Weiss, “The Vision of Constantine”. Journal of Roman Archaeology 16 (2003) pp 237-59. Barnes adduces pictures of solar halos from Sky and Telescope 54 (1977/8), p185 – available to me.

The TV Ancient Rome meteorite notion reflects the theory proposed some years earlier (BBC news bulletin “Space Impact Suvod Christianity” 23 June 2003) by Swedish geologist Jens Ormo who claimed to have found the actual crater and confirmed its right time period by radiocarbon dating.

For some entertaining fictions, see Colin Thubron’s novel Emperor (Penguin, 1991) Fort of course abounds with solar phenomena and meteorites.

Mahoney is right to emphasise links with solar worship, especially Sol Invictus. The latter, previously number one with emperor Aurelian (270-275) was the patron deity of Constantine’s imperial father Constantius (Barnes, pp 12+290,n38 for source references). Constantine, soon after this battle and for several years afterwards, continued to strike coins (above) linking himself iconographically with this solar patron (Barnes, pp36, 48, 309, nn 47,49).

Apart from dreams and visions, Constantine was also beneficiary of a historical fraud, namely the invention by one of his anonymous Latin panegyricists (no6, para2, cf. the Augustan History’s biography of Claudius, ch1 para3. plus Barnes,vpp35, 301 nn60-2) of a family connection with the perfect prince Claudius II (258-70).

Given this and his distinctly un-Christian rule (e.g.,  liquidation of son Crispus and wife Fausta, barbarous punishments for errant slaves, reduction of the peasantry to serfdom), redeemed – the hoped – by death-bed baptism at the hands of Eusebius, we are justified in pronouncing his name CON-stantine.

Classical Corner 138: Fortean Times 276 (June, 2011), p. 19.

Advertisements

#Thelxinoe ~ Your Morning Salutatio for August 30, 2019

Hodie est a.d. III Kal. Septembres 2772 AUC ~  1 Boedromion in the third year of the 699th Olympiad

In the News

Public Facing Classics

Fresh Bloggery

Fresh Podcasts

How did the ancient Greeks think about technology? Were they techno-optimists or pessimists? How do their myths – of Pandora, Odysseus, Talos, and Icarus – parallel to the technological possibilities that we’ve uncovered in the present? And what can we learn from these narratives? In this episode, I explore these questions and more with Dr. Adrienne Mayor, the author of Gods and Robots: Myths, Machines, and Ancient Dreams of Technology.

Book Reviews

Dramatic Receptions

Professional Matters

Alia

‘Sorting’ Out Your Day:

Today on the Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar:

If it should thunder today, it portends the outbreak of disease in the city where the thunder rumbles.

… adapted from the text and translation of:

Jean MacIntosh Turfa, The Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar, in Nancy Thomson de Grummond and Erika Simon (eds.), The Religion of the Etruscans. University of Texas Press, 2006. (Kindle edition)

#Thelxinoe ~ Your Morning Salutatio for August 29, 2019

Hodie est a.d. IV Kal. Septembres 2772 AUC ~  29 Metageitnion in the third year of the 699th Olympiad

In the News

In Case You Missed It

Greek/Latin News

Public Facing Classics

Fresh Bloggery

Fresh Podcasts

Tiberius runs amok. Usury runs rampant. Drusus chews the stuffing.

Dr Radness travelled to Melbourne recently and met with the fantastic and erudite Dr Rhiannon Evans from La Trobe. Dr Evans is one of the famous voices on the Emperors of Rome podcast. In this special episode, Dr Rad and Dr Evans explore barbarians!

Melvyn Bragg and guests discuss St Augustine’s account of his life, sometimes called the first autobiography, written around AD397 after he had been appointed as Bishop of Hippo

Book Reviews

Dramatic Receptions

Alia

‘Sorting’ Out Your Day:

Today on the Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar:

If it should rain today, it does not portend a reversal of fate.

… adapted from the text and translation of:

Jean MacIntosh Turfa, The Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar, in Nancy Thomson de Grummond and Erika Simon (eds.), The Religion of the Etruscans. University of Texas Press, 2006. (Kindle edition)

#Thelxinoe ~ Your Morning Salutatio for August 28, 2019

Hodie est a.d. V Kal. Septembres 2772 AUC ~  28 Metageitnion in the third year of the 699th Olympiad

In the News

In Case You Missed It

Public Facing Classics

Fresh Bloggery

Fresh Podcasts

Elagabalus has long been remembered as deviant and sexually depraved. His behaviour was shocking for a Roman citizen, let alone the leader of the empire, and Rome was relieved to see the end of him.

Guest: Dr Caillan Davenport (Senior Lecturer, Roman History, Macquarie University/Humboldt Research Fellow, Goethe University, Frankfurt)

Hello my friends today, my guest is Donald Robertson. Donald was born in Irvine, Scotland, and he became a specialist in teaching evidence-based psychological skills. Known as an expert on the relationship between modern cognitive behavioral therapy and classical Greek and Roman philosophy. Who merges those two things? And if that wasn’t enough, he was … Continue reading “Donald Robertson: How To Think Like A Roman Emperor”

Professional Matters

Alia

‘Sorting’ Out Your Day:

Today on the Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar:

If it should thunder today, it portends both an abundance of crops and death of cattle.

… adapted from the text and translation of:

Jean MacIntosh Turfa, The Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar, in Nancy Thomson de Grummond and Erika Simon (eds.), The Religion of the Etruscans. University of Texas Press, 2006. (Kindle edition)

#Thelxinoe ~ Your Morning Salutatio for August 27, 2019

Hodie est a.d. VI Kal. Septembres 2772 AUC ~  27 Metageitnion in the third year of the 699th Olympiad

… slow day … classes must have resumed

In the News

In Case You Missed It

 

Fresh Bloggery

 

Book Reviews

Professional Matters

Alia

‘Sorting’ Out Your Day:

Today on the Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar:

If it should thunder today, it portends wars and conspiracies.

… adapted from the text and translation of:

Jean MacIntosh Turfa, The Etruscan Brontoscopic Calendar, in Nancy Thomson de Grummond and Erika Simon (eds.), The Religion of the Etruscans. University of Texas Press, 2006. (Kindle edition)